Dave's Pizza Garage

Casey Strickland 2 months ago

Placed a pick up order much earlier in the day for pick up at 4 PM. Got there at 4 PM and the place was dead. Told the two young ladies that I was here for my pick up order. They had not started it yet, and I had food in the car waiting. This is why I made the pick up order for 4 PM. Pure laziness and not a manager in sight. They looked like two high school girls. The cheesesteak was phenomenal though! Definitely the best in Tallahassee. Fly By Philly’s is a very close second.

Erin Petkus 5 months ago

Dave from Dave’s Pizza Garage was absolutely fantastic and such an important part of making our wedding day so special. From the very beginning, he went above and beyond - inviting us to come try samples so we could choose exactly what we wanted. That level of care and attention meant a lot, and it made the whole process feel personal and enjoyable. Dave himself is incredibly kind and easy to work with, which made everything stress-free. On the day of the wedding, the food was outstanding. The pizza, pasta salad, pizza logs. Everything he served was absolutely delicious and prepared perfectly. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about how good the food was, and we received so many compliments throughout the night. It was clear that Dave takes pride in what he does, and it truly shows in both the quality of the food and his service. If you’re looking for pizza or a caterer who delivers amazing food and an equally great experience, Dave is the one. We are so grateful we chose him.

kip star 7 months ago

This place is dope. Pizza, wings, sandwiches are all amazing. Clean dining area and bathrooms. Awesome monthly newsletter and coupons. Staff is really nice and helpful. I would be friends with Dave personally if I could.

Markus Shoplak a year ago

No,no,no,no!!!! This should be a dive bar versus a pizza restaurant. The pizza honestly is better on a cruise ship! The sauce was very tomato paste like and cheese blend is not good. The calzone again is not good even when trying to dip it in the marinara. Dough needs a lot of help, maybe change from using members mark products. The prices for the pizza products are over prices!! We left this sitting on the table and could not eat. Now, there was a couple of maybes that drove me to lean towards being a dive bar. The boneless wings (cut chicken breast) were edible and truly was not bad. The “poutine” was not a true poutine,but will suffice. Slices cheese thrown on some fries and completely drowned in gravy can satisfy the craving when you are wanting poutine. The brownie cookie was tasty!!

Brian Andrews 2 years ago

Wish I'd come here earlier. Pizza was best in town, and I love some of the other local pizza places. But crust was amazing, sauce good, didn't skimp on toppings. Had the lunch special, which was generous and didn't break the bank (around $10 for personal pizza, cookie and drink) A bit hidden, but it means easy parking. Also nice that they have plenty of activities for kids, as well as a kids menu. Staff was very nice and good came out quickly. If you haven't been out here, I'd highly recommend swinging by at least once!